{
  "schema": 1,
  "experiment_id": "orin-controller-pilot-v2",
  "status": "pass",
  "scope": "deterministic exploratory sensitivity matrix; scenario cells reuse the same 320 tiles and are not independent samples",
  "provenance": {
    "matrix_summary_sha256": "2a7de652bc9eeb703ce6677501c6c75a9a1ea2b634c0599ee5baf9cbbcba572a",
    "smoke_summary_sha256": "e14d79bedd6c84a3e13d3e6221909997cb9b660e1355be78099e76b9c54ceb98",
    "telemetry_summary_sha256": "417aa2f9628bdd19f6af215eec6700cfbecae0fd7f2c00cf27998291bca7ce30"
  },
  "matrix": {
    "scenario_cells": 60,
    "policy_runs": 240,
    "task_events": 76800,
    "comparisons": 180
  },
  "integrity": {
    "runs": 240,
    "total_engine_prediction_mismatches_vs_reference": 0,
    "total_profiled_safety_violations": 0,
    "answers_present_during_hardware_execution": false
  },
  "smoke_gates": {
    "status": "pass",
    "cell": {
      "trace": "combined",
      "workload": "near",
      "false_clear_cost": 5.0
    },
    "observed": {
      "nomos_completed_tasks": 320,
      "nomos_model_switches": 2,
      "total_engine_prediction_mismatches": 0,
      "total_profiled_safety_violations": 0,
      "answer_key_present_during_execution": false
    },
    "checks": {
      "nomos_completed_tasks": true,
      "nomos_model_switches": true,
      "engine_prediction_mismatches": true,
      "profiled_safety_violations": true,
      "answer_key_absent_during_execution": true
    },
    "full_matrix_allowed": true
  },
  "policy_totals": {
    "best_static": {
      "cells": 60,
      "completed_cell_tasks": 15360,
      "possible_cell_tasks": 19200,
      "mean_normalized_utility": 0.6798541666666666,
      "summed_profiled_energy_j": 516.8974819697884,
      "model_switches": 0,
      "frequency_switches": 0
    },
    "fixed_schedule": {
      "cells": 60,
      "completed_cell_tasks": 15360,
      "possible_cell_tasks": 19200,
      "mean_normalized_utility": 0.6798541666666666,
      "summed_profiled_energy_j": 516.8974819697884,
      "model_switches": 0,
      "frequency_switches": 0
    },
    "adaptive_dvfs": {
      "cells": 60,
      "completed_cell_tasks": 17856,
      "possible_cell_tasks": 19200,
      "mean_normalized_utility": 0.79553125,
      "summed_profiled_energy_j": 667.1560013194222,
      "model_switches": 0,
      "frequency_switches": 52
    },
    "nomos": {
      "cells": 60,
      "completed_cell_tasks": 19160,
      "possible_cell_tasks": 19200,
      "mean_normalized_utility": 0.8474583333333334,
      "summed_profiled_energy_j": 646.4047881012087,
      "model_switches": 8,
      "frequency_switches": 60
    }
  },
  "nomos_vs_baselines": {
    "best_static": {
      "cells": 60,
      "utility": {
        "win": 30,
        "tie": 30,
        "loss": 0
      },
      "completion": {
        "win": 30,
        "tie": 30,
        "loss": 0
      },
      "lower_profiled_energy": {
        "win": 0,
        "tie": 30,
        "loss": 30
      },
      "mean_utility_delta": 0.16760416666666667,
      "mean_completion_delta": 63.333333333333336,
      "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": 2.1584551021903393,
      "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
      "maximum_utility_delta": 0.35625000000000007
    },
    "fixed_schedule": {
      "cells": 60,
      "utility": {
        "win": 30,
        "tie": 30,
        "loss": 0
      },
      "completion": {
        "win": 30,
        "tie": 30,
        "loss": 0
      },
      "lower_profiled_energy": {
        "win": 0,
        "tie": 30,
        "loss": 30
      },
      "mean_utility_delta": 0.16760416666666667,
      "mean_completion_delta": 63.333333333333336,
      "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": 2.1584551021903393,
      "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
      "maximum_utility_delta": 0.35625000000000007
    },
    "adaptive_dvfs": {
      "cells": 60,
      "utility": {
        "win": 12,
        "tie": 48,
        "loss": 0
      },
      "completion": {
        "win": 12,
        "tie": 48,
        "loss": 0
      },
      "lower_profiled_energy": {
        "win": 8,
        "tie": 48,
        "loss": 4
      },
      "mean_utility_delta": 0.05192708333333333,
      "mean_completion_delta": 21.733333333333334,
      "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.34585355363689246,
      "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
      "maximum_utility_delta": 0.47250000000000003
    }
  },
  "nomos_vs_adaptive_dvfs": {
    "overall": {
      "cells": 60,
      "utility": {
        "win": 12,
        "tie": 48,
        "loss": 0
      },
      "completion": {
        "win": 12,
        "tie": 48,
        "loss": 0
      },
      "lower_profiled_energy": {
        "win": 8,
        "tie": 48,
        "loss": 4
      },
      "mean_utility_delta": 0.05192708333333333,
      "mean_completion_delta": 21.733333333333334,
      "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.34585355363689246,
      "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
      "maximum_utility_delta": 0.47250000000000003
    },
    "by_false_clear_cost": {
      "0.5": {
        "cells": 12,
        "utility": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "mean_completion_delta": 0.0,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": 0.0,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.0
      },
      "1.0": {
        "cells": 12,
        "utility": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "mean_completion_delta": 0.0,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": 0.0,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.0
      },
      "10.0": {
        "cells": 12,
        "utility": {
          "win": 6,
          "tie": 6,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 6,
          "tie": 6,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 6,
          "loss": 2
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.12890625,
        "mean_completion_delta": 54.333333333333336,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.8646338840922311,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.47062499999999996
      },
      "2.0": {
        "cells": 12,
        "utility": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "mean_completion_delta": 0.0,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": 0.0,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.0
      },
      "5.0": {
        "cells": 12,
        "utility": {
          "win": 6,
          "tie": 6,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 6,
          "tie": 6,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 6,
          "loss": 2
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.13072916666666667,
        "mean_completion_delta": 54.333333333333336,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.8646338840922311,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.47250000000000003
      }
    },
    "by_trace": {
      "benign": {
        "cells": 15,
        "utility": {
          "win": 2,
          "tie": 13,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 2,
          "tie": 13,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 2,
          "tie": 13,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.031187499999999996,
        "mean_completion_delta": 14.133333333333333,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.5152593412378359,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.23687499999999995
      },
      "combined": {
        "cells": 15,
        "utility": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 11,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 11,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 2,
          "tie": 11,
          "loss": 2
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.07266666666666667,
        "mean_completion_delta": 29.333333333333332,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.17644776603594903,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.47250000000000003
      },
      "energy_shortfall": {
        "cells": 15,
        "utility": {
          "win": 2,
          "tie": 13,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 2,
          "tie": 13,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 2,
          "tie": 13,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.031187499999999996,
        "mean_completion_delta": 14.133333333333333,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.5152593412378359,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.23687499999999995
      },
      "power_cap_transient": {
        "cells": 15,
        "utility": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 11,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 11,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 2,
          "tie": 11,
          "loss": 2
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.07266666666666667,
        "mean_completion_delta": 29.333333333333332,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.17644776603594903,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.47250000000000003
      }
    },
    "by_workload": {
      "near": {
        "cells": 20,
        "utility": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 16,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 16,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 16,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.01468750000000001,
        "mean_completion_delta": 6.4,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.5373295933375161,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.07500000000000007
      },
      "over": {
        "cells": 20,
        "utility": {
          "win": 8,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 8,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 4,
          "tie": 12,
          "loss": 4
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.14109375,
        "mean_completion_delta": 58.8,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": -0.5002310675731613,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.47250000000000003
      },
      "under": {
        "cells": 20,
        "utility": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 20,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "completion": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 20,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "lower_profiled_energy": {
          "win": 0,
          "tie": 20,
          "loss": 0
        },
        "mean_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "mean_completion_delta": 0.0,
        "mean_profiled_energy_delta_j": 0.0,
        "minimum_utility_delta": 0.0,
        "maximum_utility_delta": 0.0
      }
    },
    "nonzero_cells": [
      {
        "trace": "benign",
        "workload": "over",
        "false_clear_cost": 5.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.23687499999999995,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 106,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": -3.864445059283769
      },
      {
        "trace": "benign",
        "workload": "over",
        "false_clear_cost": 10.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.23093750000000002,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 106,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": -3.864445059283769
      },
      {
        "trace": "combined",
        "workload": "near",
        "false_clear_cost": 5.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.07500000000000007,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 32,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": -2.6866479666875804
      },
      {
        "trace": "combined",
        "workload": "near",
        "false_clear_cost": 10.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.07187500000000002,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 32,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": -2.6866479666875804
      },
      {
        "trace": "combined",
        "workload": "over",
        "false_clear_cost": 5.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.47250000000000003,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 188,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": 1.3632897214179627
      },
      {
        "trace": "combined",
        "workload": "over",
        "false_clear_cost": 10.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.47062499999999996,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 188,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": 1.3632897214179627
      },
      {
        "trace": "energy_shortfall",
        "workload": "over",
        "false_clear_cost": 5.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.23687499999999995,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 106,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": -3.864445059283769
      },
      {
        "trace": "energy_shortfall",
        "workload": "over",
        "false_clear_cost": 10.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.23093750000000002,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 106,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": -3.864445059283769
      },
      {
        "trace": "power_cap_transient",
        "workload": "near",
        "false_clear_cost": 5.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.07500000000000007,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 32,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": -2.6866479666875804
      },
      {
        "trace": "power_cap_transient",
        "workload": "near",
        "false_clear_cost": 10.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.07187500000000002,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 32,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": -2.6866479666875804
      },
      {
        "trace": "power_cap_transient",
        "workload": "over",
        "false_clear_cost": 5.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.47250000000000003,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 188,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": 1.3632897214179627
      },
      {
        "trace": "power_cap_transient",
        "workload": "over",
        "false_clear_cost": 10.0,
        "baseline": "adaptive_dvfs",
        "utility_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 0.47062499999999996,
        "completion_delta_nomos_minus_baseline": 188,
        "profiled_energy_delta_j_nomos_minus_baseline": 1.3632897214179627
      }
    ],
    "completed_cell_task_delta": 1304,
    "profiled_energy_delta_j": -20.75121321821348,
    "profiled_energy_relative_change": -0.031103989437514135
  },
  "controller_stability": {
    "nomos_model_switch_histogram": {
      "0": 56,
      "2": 4
    },
    "maximum_nomos_model_switches_in_a_cell": 2,
    "nomos_completion_histogram": {
      "316": 10,
      "320": 50
    }
  },
  "controls": {
    "static_fixed_cells_with_different_outcomes": 0,
    "energy_shortfall_matches_benign": true,
    "smoke_repeat": {
      "best_static": {
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields": [
          "completed",
          "normalized_mission_utility",
          "profiled_energy_j",
          "model_switches",
          "frequency_switches",
          "model_counts",
          "frequency_counts"
        ]
      },
      "fixed_schedule": {
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields": [
          "completed",
          "normalized_mission_utility",
          "profiled_energy_j",
          "model_switches",
          "frequency_switches",
          "model_counts",
          "frequency_counts"
        ]
      },
      "adaptive_dvfs": {
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields": [
          "completed",
          "normalized_mission_utility",
          "profiled_energy_j",
          "model_switches",
          "frequency_switches",
          "model_counts",
          "frequency_counts"
        ]
      },
      "nomos": {
        "exact_match": true,
        "fields": [
          "completed",
          "normalized_mission_utility",
          "profiled_energy_j",
          "model_switches",
          "frequency_switches",
          "model_counts",
          "frequency_counts"
        ]
      }
    }
  },
  "maximum_probability_difference_vs_reference": 0.0081138014793396,
  "physical_telemetry": {
    "all_samples": 4833,
    "active_gpu_samples": 4696,
    "mean_gpu_percent": 45.92206132879046,
    "mean_board_power_w": 7.48066503407155,
    "peak_board_power_w": 9.185,
    "peak_temperature_c": 52.812,
    "peak_ram_used_mb": 2078
  },
  "interpretation": [
    "Nomos tied adaptive DVFS in 48/60 cells and won in 12/60; it lost in none within this frozen synthetic matrix.",
    "All 12 Nomos-over-DVFS wins occurred at false-clear costs 5 or 10 under near or over load; lower cost ratios and every underloaded cell tied.",
    "Eight DVFS comparisons used less profiled energy under Nomos, four used more because Nomos completed 188 additional tasks, and 48 tied.",
    "The energy-shortfall trace was non-binding and exactly matched benign outcomes.",
    "These deterministic cells reuse one shard and one profile table; win counts are sensitivity-map coverage, not statistical evidence or customer economics."
  ]
}